Mesorhizobium: The Specialist Microbe That Supercharges Legume Yields

I'm going to start this one by telling you what Mesorhizobium won't do for you.

It will not fix nitrogen for your green beans. Won't do a thing for your sugar snap peas either. And if some fella at the garden center sells you a Mesorhizobium inoculant and tells you to dust it on your bush bean seed before planting, well, you have been sold a very expensive bag of nothing and I'm sorry you had to hear it from me.

Strange way to open a microbe spotlight, I know. But this one sits different from the rest of the series and I've come around to thinking the difference is the actual point of writing it up. Most of the bacteria we've covered so far, your Azospirillum and your Pseudomonas and Bacillus, they're generalists. Help just about anything green. Mesorhizobium don't work like that at all. It's a specialist. And when a specialist finds the one partner it was built for, it does things no generalist is ever going to match.

So let's get into what it actually is, which plants it bothers showing up for, and how you go about checking whether any of it is happening down in your own dirt. Because after a lot of years talking to gardeners I've noticed almost nobody does the one thing that would settle the question. They plant their beans, figure the nitrogen magic is going on somewhere below the mulch line, and get all the way to frost without ever pulling up a root to look.

Nodules sliced open under magnification. That pink is the whole story.

What Mesorhizobium actually is

Mesorhizobium is a genus of soil bacteria that forms root nodules on certain legumes and fixes nitrogen inside them.

The "meso" part means middle. It grows faster than Bradyrhizobium, the slow one that handles soybeans and peanuts, and slower than Rhizobium, the quick one your beans and peas rely on. So somebody named an entire genus after how fast it grows in a petri dish. Which tells you plenty about how scientists name things.

The star of the genus is Mesorhizobium ciceri. That's the one that nodulates chickpeas, or garbanzo beans if that's what they were called in your mother's kitchen, and it has been the commercial chickpea inoculant in Australia for going on forty years now. A close cousin called Mesorhizobium mediterraneum covers the same ground across a good bit of the rest of the world.

What happens down there when the partnership works:

• Your chickpea root leaks flavonoids into the soil. Chemical signals, basically a dinner invitation.
• Mesorhizobium reads the signal and answers back with molecules called Nod factors.
• The root hair curls around the bacteria and builds an infection thread, like a tunnel, pulling them inside.
• The plant grows a nodule, a purpose-built house, and the bacteria move in.
• Inside, the bacteria transform into bacteroids and switch on nitrogenase, the enzyme that cracks nitrogen gas out of thin air.

The plant pays rent in sugar, the bacteria pay in nitrogen, and not one bit of it is charity. This is a lease agreement that both parties spent something like a hundred million years negotiating, and if either side stops holding up its end the whole thing gets terminated in a hurry.

Seventy-eight percent of the air your chickpeas are standing in is nitrogen. They can't touch a molecule of it. Mesorhizobium can.

The specialist problem: your beans and your chickpeas don't share a microbe

This is the part that trips folks up. Tripped me up for years, and I'm supposed to be the one with the chemistry degree.

The legume-rhizobia relationship is specific. Not "sort of specific." Specific like a key and a lock. University of Minnesota Extension notes there are 238 known rhizobia species, and the wrong one won't form nodules on your plant at all. Not fewer nodules. Zero.

So next time you pick up a little jar of "garden legume inoculant" off the shelf at the hardware store, flip it over first. Read the back. A decent one will tell you flat out which crops it actually works on, and if it doesn't name any, that's your answer right there.

Look down that last column. One yes. Seven rows and one yes, and that is the specialist problem in a nutshell.

It also explains something I hear from gardeners about once a week, which is some version of "I planted beans to put nitrogen back in my soil and nothing happened." Well. Maybe nothing did. If that ground has never grown that particular legume before, and the right rhizobia aren't already living down there waiting, then your beans came up and grew like any other plant in the row and fixed exactly nothing.

Beans and peas in the same bed. Different microbes underneath, doing the same job.

The strangest thing about this microbe, and it's genuinely strange

Indulge me a minute here. This next bit is the whole reason I wanted to write the post.

Mesorhizobium keeps its nitrogen-fixing instructions on a mobile chunk of DNA called a symbiosis island. Researchers who sequenced M. ciceri strain CC1192 found the nodulation and nitrogen-fixation genes sitting on a 419-kilobase island inside the chromosome, flanked by repeat sequences, packing its own machinery for cutting itself out and moving.

Which means this. A plain ordinary non-symbiotic Mesorhizobium sitting in your soil, one that has never nodulated a thing in its entire existence, can go and acquire the ability. The island transfers over. And the bacterium on the receiving end wakes up one morning knowing how to build a chickpea nodule.

It's the closest thing soil biology has to handing someone a skill on a flash drive.

There's something practical buried in that, though. All those background soil bacteria you never think about are not just standing around being bystanders. That crowd is the pool your symbionts get recruited out of. Which means a soil full of living microbial diversity isn't only healthier this season, it's carrying more raw material for whatever your garden needs three years from now.

Pink inside means the nodule is working. That color is leghemoglobin, chemically a cousin of the hemoglobin in your own blood.

How to know if it's actually working: go dig one up

No lab required. A trowel and about four minutes will do it.

Wait until your legumes are right around flowering, since that's when fixation peaks. Then go dig up one plant, carefully, taking as much root as you can get. Just the one. I promise you'll survive the loss. Rinse those roots off in a bucket of water until you can see what you're looking at.

Now look for the bumps. Round or oblong growths clinging to the roots. Those are nodules.

Then slice one open with your thumbnail:

• Pink or reddish inside means you're in business. That's leghemoglobin, the protein that manages oxygen levels so the nitrogenase enzyme doesn't get poisoned. Active fixation.
• White, gray, or green inside means the nodule formed but it's not fixing. Either the strain is a poor performer or something is stressing the plant.
• No nodules at all means the right bacteria aren't there. Inoculate before you plant next season.

For reference, New Mexico State Extension puts a well-nodulated bean plant at fewer than 100 nodules, where a soybean might be carrying several hundred, and chickpeas land somewhere in between. Not that you're counting. You're just confirming they exist and they're pink inside.

Five things that shut nitrogen fixation down

You can have exactly the right microbe present in exactly the right soil and still end up with nothing to show for it. These are the five things that get in the way.

1. Too much nitrogen. This is the big one. Legumes are opportunists. If there's easy nitrogen sitting in the soil from a synthetic feed or a heavy manure application, the plant will take the free lunch and skip the expense of feeding a bacterial tenant. Fixation drops off hard. It's one more reason I keep coming back to the difference between organic and synthetic feeding.
2. Low pH. Below about 6.0, rhizobia struggle to survive in soil. If you've never checked, this is worth a soil test, and my guide to soil pH for vegetables walks through the fix.
3. Low phosphorus. Colorado State Extension found that adding phosphorus increases nodule count, nodule weight, and the amount of nitrogen fixed per nodule. Nodules are metabolically expensive. They run on phosphorus. Bacteria like Rahnella and Acinetobacter are the ones prying it loose.
4. Drought and heat stress. Stressed legumes will literally shed their nodules. It's a triage decision.
5. Dead soil. If the microbial community is gone, burned out by years of synthetic inputs, you don't just lose the symbiont. You lose the whole supporting cast that keeps the symbiont alive between seasons. I wrote about what that actually costs you if you want the long version.

So does Plant Juice contain Mesorhizobium? Yes. Here's the honest answer.

Alright. Straight answer, because I'd rather keep your trust than move another bottle.

When we sent Plant Juice to BiomeMakers for third-party DNA sequencing (report CUX005), the lab identified 291 microbial species. Mesorhizobium was one of them. Specifically Mesorhizobium sp., at 9,050 cells per milliliter, ranking 131st by abundance out of those 291.

And it wasn't in there by itself. Five different nodule-forming rhizobia genera turned up in that same report:

Now the part where I talk myself out of a sale.

Plant Juice is still not a chickpea inoculant, and I'm not going to sell it as one. Two reasons, and they both matter.

• The ID stops at the genus. The sequencing tells us Mesorhizobium is present. It does not tell us the species. I cannot tell you it's M. ciceri, the chickpea specialist, because the test doesn't resolve that far. Could be. Might not be.
• The dose isn't an inoculant dose. A commercial seed inoculant delivers billions of cells of one targeted strain, right onto the seed coat, where the root will be. Nine thousand cells per mL spread across a watering can is a different thing entirely.

So if chickpeas are going into ground that has never grown chickpeas before, go buy the chickpea-specific inoculant. Costs a few dollars. Nothing I make is a substitute for it and I'd be doing you dirty to pretend different.

What we do make is the soil those bacteria have got to live in once they arrive.

The BiomeMakers functional analysis of that same 291-species community found:

• 27% solubilize phosphorus. Remember the Colorado State finding, that phosphorus drives nodule number and nitrogen fixed per nodule. Microbes like Pseudomonas putida (the 4th most abundant species in the bottle) unlock phosphorus that's already sitting in your soil, chemically locked up and unavailable.
• 82% produce ACC deaminase. This enzyme lowers stress ethylene in plant roots. Ethylene is a known brake on nodule formation, and some Mesorhizobium strains carry genes specifically to manage it.
• 80% contribute to inorganic nitrogen release, and the community includes Rhizobium sp. alongside Flavobacterium sp. and Devosia insulae.
• 84% produce auxin (IAA), the hormone that drives root hair development. Root hairs are literally the doorway rhizobia enter through.

Think of it this way. You're buying the tenant when you buy an inoculant. What we sell is the neighborhood they have to move into.

Same goes for Ancient Soil, our Class A certified compost worm castings. Castings feed the whole underground food web and they buffer pH while they're at it, which quietly takes care of two of the five problems on that list up above.

What gardeners are seeing

★★★★★

"I can't believe how everything is growing so well! The stuff really stinks, but the plants love it. The radishes were the biggest I have ever had and the bean plants are just loaded with beautiful long green beans. So many that I had to stake each plant to keep them from falling over."

— Susan N., verified purchase

★★★★★

"This the best vegetable garden yet!! Even though my tomato plants have a virus it's still producing leaves and fruit. My long sweet pepper plants are 5' high. Wow"

— Nancy S., verified purchase

★★★★★

"My garden was slow to get going so I gave it some Plant Booster along with my house plants and they are all very happy. I just did a second planting of radishes as the first planting is gone and so yummy! I've been very happy with this product."

— Sheila H., verified purchase

Frequently asked questions

What is Mesorhizobium, in one sentence?

A genus of nitrogen-fixing soil bacteria that builds root nodules on specific legumes, chickpeas above all, and converts nitrogen gas from the air into a form the plant can actually eat.

Will Mesorhizobium help my green beans?

No. Beans partner with Rhizobium. Peas and lentils partner with Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae. Soybeans want Bradyrhizobium. Match the inoculant to the crop or you'll get no nodules at all.

Does Plant Juice contain Mesorhizobium?

Yes. BiomeMakers DNA sequencing (report CUX005) detected Mesorhizobium sp. at 9,050 cells/mL, 131st of 291 species. Two limits worth stating plainly: the ID is genus-level, not the chickpea specialist M. ciceri, and the concentration is nowhere near a commercial inoculant dose. Buy the inoculant. Then build the soil.

Do I need to re-inoculate every year?

Not necessarily. Rhizobia can survive in soil for years in a dormant state once established. But if you've never grown that legume in that spot, or it's been more than about five years, inoculate. It's cheap insurance.

My peas made tons of vines but no pods. Related?

Probably a nitrogen surplus, and it's a classic. Excess nitrogen gives you gorgeous foliage, suppresses nodulation, and delays flowering. Back off the nitrogen and let the plant get a little hungry.

How many rhizobia species are there?

238 known species, per University of Minnesota Extension. Each partners with a narrow range of legume hosts. That's why an all-purpose legume inoculant doesn't exist.

Bean teepees earning their keep. Nitrogen for the neighbors, if the right bacteria showed up.

Keep reading

• Rhizobium: the nitrogen-fixer your beans and peas actually want
• Bradyrhizobium and better root development
• Azotobacter: the nitrogen-fixer that doesn't need a plant partner
• The nitrogen cycle in your garden, explained simply
• Soil pH for vegetables: what your legumes need
• Organic vegetable gardening: the full guide
• Shop the Vegetable Garden Success collection

Sources

• Complete Genome Sequence of Mesorhizobium ciceri Strain CC1192 — Genome Announcements (PMC)
• Mesorhizobium ciceri overview — ScienceDirect
• Inoculating garden legumes — University of Minnesota Extension
• Legume seed inoculants — Colorado State University Extension
• Nitrogen fixation by legumes — New Mexico State University Extension
• BiomeMakers third-party DNA sequencing, report CUX005 (Elm Dirt Plant Juice), 291 species identified

Lauren Cain

Founder & Chemical Engineer, Elm Dirt — Grandview, MO

Lauren started Elm Dirt after her infant daughter ate a fistful of backyard dirt and she realized she had no idea what was in it. She's a chemical engineer and a mom, and she built Elm Dirt's fertilizers around living soil biology instead of synthetic salts. Today they're used by home gardeners, rose champions, and organic growers across the country.