Leachate vs Worm Tea: Why One Helps Plants and One Hurts Them

Leachate vs Worm Tea: Why One Helps Plants and One Hurts Them | Elm Dirt
Premium organic worm castings soil amendment in garden setting

Here's something that confuses a lot of people: leachate and worm tea look almost identical, but they do completely different things to your plants. One is liquid gold for your garden, and the other? Well, it can actually harm your plants. Let's break down the difference so you never mix them up again.

❌ Leachate: Don't Use This

The liquid that drains from your worm bin. Contains harmful pathogens, bad microorganisms, high salt levels, and potential contaminants like heavy metals and pesticides. Can damage plants and strip nutrients from soil.

✅ Worm Tea: Use This!

Brewed from worm castings (worm poop). Packed with beneficial microbes and nutrients. A natural liquid fertilizer that helps plants thrive without burning them. Also known as "liquid gold" among gardeners.

Person watering healthy money tree plant with liquid fertilizer

What is Leachate?

Leachate happens when you've got excess water in your worm bin. Here's how it works: those food scraps you feed your worms are mostly water. As the worms and other microorganisms break down that organic matter, even more water gets released. All this liquid eventually makes its way to the bottom of your bin or leaves the bedding soaking wet.

Too much moisture can lead to a smelly bin and—worse—sick worms. And that liquid sitting at the bottom? It might look like it could be beneficial for your plants, but unfortunately, it's not.

Critical Warning: Leachate is anaerobic (lacks oxygen), which means it's a breeding ground for harmful bacteria and pathogens. This is exactly what you don't want anywhere near your plants, especially anything edible.

What is Worm Tea?

Close-up of rich dark worm castings showing texture and quality

Worm tea is brewed from worm castings—also known as worm poop (let's just call it what it is). It's a liquid fertilizer absolutely packed with beneficial microbes and nutrients that you use to water your plants and garden instead of plain water.

If you're not familiar with worm castings, here's the quick version: composting worms eat and break down organic matter—food waste, paper, cardboard, leaves, even animal waste. Everything compostable, basically. As this organic matter moves through the worm's digestive tract, beneficial microbes and nutrients get packed into mucus-coated waste called castings.

This is why people call it liquid gold! You're getting soil that's loaded with beneficial microbes and nutrients that plants absolutely love.

Rich compost material showing decomposed organic matter and earthworms

Why You Should Never Use Leachate on Plants

Let's be crystal clear about this: leachate is bad news for your garden. Here's why you should stay away from it:

Leachate often contains harmful microorganisms and pathogens that can damage your plants and garden. It especially shouldn't be used on edible plants because of contamination risks—you definitely don't want to eat vegetables that have been exposed to harmful bacteria.

On top of that, leachate can contain super high levels of salt, which isn't good for your plants and actually strips nutrients from the soil instead of adding them. And here's the kicker: leachate can also contain pollutants and contaminants that were in the original organic material, like heavy metals, pesticides, and pathogens.

How to Dispose of Leachate: Pour it down the sink or toilet, or dump it on your driveway. Just keep it away from grass and garden areas. The key is getting it away from any plants you care about.
Healthy money tree plant thriving with proper care and nutrition

How to Make Worm Tea at Home

Worm Tea Recipe

  1. Place worm castings in a mesh bag—something like a stocking or cheesecloth works perfectly.
  2. Put that bag of castings into dechlorinated water. (Let tap water sit out for 24 hours to dechlorinate, or use collected rainwater.)
  3. Brew for about 24 hours if you're using a bubbler or aerator to add oxygen. Without an aerator? Let it steep for about 48 hours.
  4. The finished tea should be a golden brown to dark brown color. That's how you know it's ready.
  5. Store your worm tea in a cool, dark place to maintain that all-important microbial activity.

What you end up with is an all-natural fertilizer that won't burn your plants, no matter how much you use. Try doing that with synthetic fertilizers!

Skip the Worm Bin, Get Premium Castings

Don't have a worm bin yet? No problem! Our Premium Organic Worm Castings are perfect for making worm tea or using directly in your soil. We've done the hard work for you—these castings are ready to use and packed with beneficial microbes.

Want an even easier option? Try our Plant Juice, which gives you all the benefits of worm tea in a concentrated, ready-to-use formula. Just dilute and water—it's that simple.

Shop Worm Castings

Preventing Excess Leachate

Tips to Keep Your Worm Bin from Getting Too Wet

  • Watch out for high-water foods like lettuce and squash. Don't add massive amounts of these at once—they'll flood your bin.
  • Balance wet foods with dry materials like shredded paper or cardboard. This absorbs excess moisture.
  • Make sure your bin has adequate drainage. If liquid is pooling at the bottom, you need better drainage.
  • Don't overwater the bin itself. Your worms get plenty of moisture from their food—they rarely need additional water added.
  • Add more bedding if things are getting too wet. Dry bedding materials will soak up that excess moisture.
Pro Tip: A healthy worm bin should feel like a wrung-out sponge—moist but not dripping. If you squeeze a handful of bedding and water drips out, it's too wet. If it feels dry and crumbly, it needs more moisture.

The Bottom Line

Yes, leachate and worm tea look similar. But that's where the similarity ends. Leachate is contaminated runoff that can harm your plants, while worm tea is a nutrient-rich brew that helps them thrive.

If you've got a worm bin and you see liquid at the bottom, don't get excited and pour it on your tomatoes. Dispose of it properly and work on reducing moisture in your bin. Save your plant feeding for actual worm tea brewed from castings—that's the good stuff your garden is craving.

Learn More About Composting and Soil Health

Want to dive deeper into creating amazing soil? Check out our guides on organic soil amendments, soil testing, and our complete guide to organic plant care. Building healthy, living soil is one of the best things you can do for your garden.

Back to blog